CC won the Cy Young, and rightfully so. He was a work-horse and was dominant down the stretch in September. But most importantly, these votes are cast at the end of the season, so any post-season performances would not cloud the writers' judgments, because, let's face it, add in the post-season and Beckett wins the award unanimously. But the writers got this one right.
Here are the voting results:
C.C. Sabathia, Indians - 19 firsts, 8 seconds - 119 points
Josh Beckett, Red Sox - 8 firsts, 14 seconds, 4 thirds - 86 points







